RESEARCH EXPLAINED · THOUGHT EXPERIMENT
Who Is Really Moving?
A Thought Experiment About Motion, Perception, and Self-Correction.
Standing in a meadow, you feel at rest. Yet Earth is spinning, orbiting the Sun, and traveling with it through the Milky Way. Whether something is at rest or moving depends on what you measure it against. This short film makes that tangible – and leads from there to a question BenchEWS investigates.
The film
Automatic start was prevented – start the film with “Play”.
The film could not be loaded here. “Play” tries again, or open the film directly: Open the film directly (MP4)
The film starts muted once it is visible and pauses when you scroll on; with the “reduce motion” setting it does not start by itself. Music can be switched on. All text is shown in the picture; “Large on-screen text” also shows it in a readable size below the video, and “Full screen” enlarges the film. A German translation can be switched on as subtitles. “Announce visual description” reads out what happens in the picture for screen readers; the transcript below contains everything in full.
The film deliberately has no narration voice: images, on-screen text and calm, specially composed music carry the message. Labels in the picture distinguish PHYSICS, ANALOGY and RESEARCH QUESTION.
Transcript with visual description
Scene 1 (0:00–0:12)
Label: none (perception, opening)
Picture: Dusk in a meadow. A person stands still; the camera slowly moves closer. Title: “Who Is Really Moving?”
Spatial layout and frame of reference: The person stands in the center of the picture in front of a low hill, with sky and the first stars above. At the end the camera tilts upward.
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 0:00–0:04 Who Is Really Moving?
- 0:01–0:04 A Thought Experiment About Motion, Perception, and Self-Correction.
- 0:02–0:06 “I am standing still.
- 0:06–0:11 At least, that is what my perception tells me.”
Scientific status and limits: Perception: standing still is an impression, not a measurement.
Scene 2 (0:12–0:26)
Label: PHYSICS · schematic
Picture: Label PHYSICS · schematic. The rotating Earth (about 0.47 km/s at the equator), then its orbit around the Sun (about 30 km/s), then the Sun's path around the galactic center (about 240 km/s). Each value refers to its own frame of reference.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: Three views in succession, each on a larger scale: first Earth alone with an arrow for its rotation, then Earth as a small dot on its orbit around the Sun, then the Sun on its path around the galactic center. Not to scale.
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 0:13–0:17 Earth's rotation · about 0.47 km/s (equator)
- 0:13–0:18 But Earth rotates, orbits the Sun,
- 0:17–0:22 Orbit around the Sun · about 30 km/s
- 0:18–0:25 and travels with it through our galaxy.
- 0:22–0:26 Sun around the galactic center · about 240 km/s
Scientific status and limits: Rounded, schematic values, not to scale. Each value refers to a different frame of reference; they combine only as vectors with direction, not by adding their magnitudes.
Scene 3 (0:26–0:42)
Label: PHYSICS · idealized thought experiment
Picture: Label PHYSICS · idealized thought experiment. A coordinate grid marks the chosen reference frame S. A person B in a spacesuit is at rest in it; Earth, with person A on its surface, passes below.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: Shown in reference frame S: B floats above the center of the picture and keeps its place. Earth, seen from above the pole, passes below B from left to right while rotating counterclockwise; A stands on its edge and rotates with it. Light trails show the path covered: Earth leaves a trail, B does not. Labeled in the picture: “A” (person on Earth) and “B” (person in a spacesuit).
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 0:26–0:43 Chosen reference frame S
- 0:26–0:43 B is at rest in S
- 0:27–0:34 Imagine a person who keeps a fixed position relative to a chosen frame of reference.
- 0:35–0:41 Earth moves past them.
Scientific status and limits: Idealized thought experiment: the gravity of Earth and Sun is neglected, over the period shown Earth moves almost uniformly relative to S, and scales are not realistic. S is a choice, not space at absolute rest.
Scene 4 (0:42–0:57)
Label: PHYSICS · idealized thought experiment
Picture: The view switches to a frame that moves with Earth's center but does not rotate: Earth's center is at rest, Earth keeps rotating (person A on its surface rotates with it), and B is moving – with identical geometry. What is shown is coordinate motion, not what A would see from Earth's surface. A small inset shows the same events in S at the same time, where B is at rest.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: Between 0:42 and 0:46 the view changes smoothly to the frame that moves with Earth's center but does not rotate. Afterwards Earth's center stays at the same place right of the center of the picture, Earth keeps rotating, the golden grid of S glides to the left, and B slowly drifts to the left – now B leaves the trail. From 0:48 a small inset at the top right shows the same events at the same time in S: there B is at rest and Earth moves to the right. The distance between Earth and B is the same in both pictures at every moment. Labeled in the picture: “A” (person on Earth) and “B” (person in a spacesuit).
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 0:43–0:48 To the people on Earth, the other person is moving.
- 0:44–0:56 Earth's center at rest – Earth keeps rotating
- 0:44–0:56 B's coordinate motion – not the view from Earth's surface
- 0:47–0:56 Same events in S: B at rest
- 0:48–0:52 To that person, Earth is moving.
- 0:52–0:56 So who is standing still?
Scientific status and limits: What is shown is coordinate motion, not optical perception. A person on Earth's surface would see B differently: because they rotate with Earth, B would cross their sky daily like a star, and B's light would reach them with a delay. Neither frame is preferred; there is no absolute rest.
Scene 5 (0:57–1:12)
Label: ANALOGY · Plato's allegory of the cave
Picture: Label ANALOGY · Plato's allegory of the cave. A cave: a fire, prisoners facing the wall, shadows of objects carried past. One person turns toward the light.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: On the left, behind the prisoners, a fire burns with a low wall in front of it; the prisoners sit with their backs to the fire and look right at the cave wall, where shadows move from left to right. Toward the end one of them turns left toward the fire and is lit from the front.
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 0:58–1:04 Plato already asked whether we know reality itself or only its shadows.
- 1:04–1:11 What do we overlook as long as we do not question our own perspective?
Scientific status and limits: Philosophical analogy, not evidence. Plato was concerned with education and his theory of Forms, not with modern measurement.
Scene 6 (1:12–1:24)
Label: RESEARCH QUESTION · synthetic curve
Picture: Label RESEARCH QUESTION · synthetic curve. A feedback loop (system → measurement → correction, feedback) and a curve: after one disturbance a quick return to the set point, after a second disturbance a slower return – marked with a question mark.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: Top left, the feedback loop of three boxes (system → measurement → correction) with an arrow “Feedback” back to the system. Below, across the width of the picture, the curve around a horizontal set-point line: a deflection after the first disturbance and a quick return; a deflection after the second disturbance and a much slower return.
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 1:12–1:17 Systems, too, must distinguish observation from cause.
- 1:12–1:24 Set point
- 1:13–1:24 System
- 1:13–1:24 Measurement
- 1:13–1:24 Correction
- 1:13–1:24 Feedback
- 1:14–1:24 Disturbance
- 1:15–1:24 Recovery
- 1:18–1:23 But how can we tell whether they are still capable of self-correction?
- 1:19–1:24 slower recovery?
Scientific status and limits: Synthetic illustration, not a measurement. A slower return is a possible warning sign, not proof that self-correction has been lost.
Scene 7 (1:24–1:30)
Label: RESEARCH QUESTION · open
Picture: Label RESEARCH QUESTION · open. Dark background, BenchEWS · Systems Science Research Programme, the closing question and www.vonmallinckrodt.com.
Spatial layout and frame of reference: Centered on a dark background: BenchEWS with its subtitle at the top, the closing question in the middle, the web address below. The picture fades out at the end.
On-screen texts (in order of appearance):
- 1:24–1:29 When does a system lose its capacity for self-correction?
- 1:24–1:29 BenchEWS
- 1:24–1:29 Systems Science Research Programme
- 1:25–1:29 www.vonmallinckrodt.com
Scientific status and limits: Open research question. An additional benefit of BenchEWS over established methods has not been demonstrated.
Audio description (continuous text)
0:00 Dusk in a meadow. A person stands still in the grass; the camera slowly moves closer. Title: Who Is Really Moving? Below: A Thought Experiment About Motion, Perception, and Self-Correction.
0:02 Text on screen: “I am standing still. At least, that is what my perception tells me.” Then the camera tilts up into the starry sky.
0:12 Label top right: PHYSICS · schematic. Earth in space; an arrow shows its rotation. Caption: Earth's rotation, about 0.47 km/s at the equator. Text: But Earth rotates, orbits the Sun,
0:17 The view widens: Earth, a small dot, travels along its orbit around the Sun. Caption: orbit around the Sun, about 30 km/s. Text: and travels with it through our galaxy.
0:22 Wider still: the Sun travels around the galactic center. Caption: about 240 km/s. Not to scale; each value refers to a different frame of reference.
0:26 New scene, label: PHYSICS · idealized thought experiment. A golden coordinate grid; top left: Chosen reference frame S. B is at rest in S. Above the center floats B, a person in a spacesuit, keeping a fixed position. Below, Earth, seen from above, approaches from left to right while rotating; the small person A stands on its edge. Text: Imagine a person who keeps a fixed position relative to a chosen frame of reference.
0:35 Earth passes below B to the right, leaving a trail of light; B stays in place. Text: Earth moves past them.
0:42 The view changes smoothly to a frame that moves with Earth's center but does not rotate. Top left now: Earth's center at rest – Earth keeps rotating. Below: B's coordinate motion – not the view from Earth's surface. Earth's center stays in place, Earth keeps rotating, the grid glides to the left, B drifts to the left. Text: To the people on Earth, the other person is moving.
0:47 A small inset appears at the top right, labeled: Same events in S: B at rest. In it B is at rest and Earth moves to the right – the same geometry, at the same time. Text: To that person, Earth is moving.
0:52 Text: So who is standing still?
0:57 New scene, label: ANALOGY · Plato's allegory of the cave. A cave: on the left a fire burns behind a low wall; prisoners sit with their backs to it, facing the wall, where the shadows of objects carried past move across. Text: Plato already asked whether we know reality itself or only its shadows.
1:04 One of the prisoners turns around toward the fire and is lit up. Text: What do we overlook as long as we do not question our own perspective?
1:12 New scene, label: RESEARCH QUESTION · synthetic curve. Top left, a feedback loop: system, measurement, correction, with an arrow, feedback, back to the system. Below, a curve runs around a horizontal line, the set point. After a disturbance it deflects and returns quickly. Text: Systems, too, must distinguish observation from cause.
1:18 A second disturbance: this time the curve returns much more slowly, labeled: slower recovery? Text: But how can we tell whether they are still capable of self-correction?
1:24 Closing picture, label: RESEARCH QUESTION · open. BenchEWS · Systems Science Research Programme. In the middle: When does a system lose its capacity for self-correction? Below: www.vonmallinckrodt.com. The picture fades out.
Note: the curves in scene 6 are synthetic illustrations, not measurements. The link between relativity, perception and BenchEWS is an epistemological analogy, not a proof. No additional benefit of BenchEWS has been demonstrated.
Physics ESTABLISHED PHYSICS
The change of perspective
- Observer
- Anyone who measures or perceives something does so from a particular place and in a particular state of motion. In the film, these are A on Earth and B in space.
- Frame of reference
- A frame of reference defines what positions and times are measured from – for instance a coordinate grid attached to Earth, to the Sun, or to an imagined point in space. Which one you choose is a decision, not a fact of nature.
- Relative motion
- In the chosen frame S, B is at rest and Earth moves past. The film then switches to a frame that moves with Earth's center but does not rotate: in it, Earth's center is at rest – Earth itself keeps rotating – and B is moving. Both pictures rest on the same geometry. In a frame that also rotates with Earth, B would even trace a looping path. There is no universal, absolute state of rest.
- What is not relative
- What can be measured is always velocity relative to something – between two bodies, for instance, via the Doppler effect. There is no absolute velocity. Rotation and proper acceleration are different: a Foucault pendulum or a gyroscope makes Earth's rotation measurable in the lab, and an accelerometer detects any thrust. Free fall, by contrast – such as Earth's fall around the Sun – feels locally unaccelerated; it reveals itself only indirectly, for instance through the tides.
- Limits of observation
- The film shows coordinate motion, not what an eye would see. A person on Earth's surface would see B differently: because they rotate with Earth, B would cross their sky once a day – like a star – and B's light would reach them with a delay. Light takes time to travel, viewing angles distort, and the scales in the film are deliberately not realistic. The thought experiment is idealized: the gravity of Earth and Sun is neglected, and over the short time shown Earth moves almost uniformly relative to S. A real person would not stay in that place without propulsion. Classical (Galilean) kinematics applies; relativistic effects are negligible at these speeds (less than a thousandth of the speed of light).
How fast are we moving?
| Earth's rotation at the equator | about 0.47 km/s (about 0.29 km/s in Wesel, Germany) | in a non-rotating, Earth-centered frame |
|---|---|---|
| Orbit around the Sun | about 29.8 km/s | in a Sun-centered frame |
| Sun around the galactic center | about 230–250 km/s | relative to the center of the Milky Way |
These values refer to different frames of reference and point in different, constantly changing directions. They combine only as vectors with direction – not by adding their magnitudes. Even the often-quoted motion relative to the cosmic microwave background (about 370 km/s) describes a particularly convenient frame – not a state of absolute rest.
Analogy PHILOSOPHICAL ANALOGY
Plato's allegory of the cave
In Plato's Republic (Book VII), people sit chained in a cave and see only the shadows of objects carried past a fire behind them. They take the shadows for reality. When one of them is freed and compelled to turn around, he is dazzled at first and still takes the shadows to be more real. Only gradually, on the arduous way out, does he begin to understand where the images come from. The film shows only the moment of turning around.
- PerceptionWhat appears to us: “I am standing still.” – “A shadow is moving over there.”
- InterpretationWhat we conclude from it – often without noticing that we assume our own standpoint is the only valid one.
- Testable knowledgeWhat can be checked independently: measurements in different frames, predictions that could fail, and an explicit statement of one's own assumptions.
Plato was concerned with education and his theory of Forms, not with modern measurement. We use the allegory as a thinking aid for an epistemological question – not as evidence. Plato, Republic VII, 514a–520a.
Research question SYSTEMS RESEARCH QUESTION
What this has to do with BenchEWS
Self-regulating technical, ecological and social systems also observe themselves and their environment – and their observation, too, is part of the dynamics. In a similar way, BenchEWS asks not only what a system measures, but whether it can still infer causes correctly from its measurements and correct itself.
- Observability
- Can a system's internal state be reconstructed from its measurements at all? An established concept in control engineering.
- Dynamic stability
- Does a system return to its operating range after a disturbance – and how quickly?
- Feedback
- Measurement, evaluation and correction form a loop. If one link is delayed, distorted or overloaded, correction suffers.
- Identifiability
- Can the causes – parameters and mechanisms – be determined uniquely from the data, or do several explanations fit equally well?
- Controllability and its limits
- Not every deviation can be corrected with the available interventions. Where are these limits?
- Recoverability
- Can a system regain its function after a disturbance? This is not the same as stability: a system can appear stable around its operating point and still fail to return after a larger disturbance. Whether two systems with identical observations can differ in this respect – and how one could tell – is one of the open questions.
When does a system lose its capacity for self-correction?
Hypothesis, not validated Working hypothesis of the programme: a loss of the capacity for self-correction announces itself in observable quantities before it occurs. Whether, and under which conditions, this holds has not been demonstrated.
The link between relativity, perception and BenchEWS is an epistemological analogy. It is neither a physical proof nor a theory of consciousness. An additional methodological benefit of BenchEWS over established methods has not been demonstrated; that investigation is ongoing. The curves in the film are synthetic illustrations, not measurements; a slower return there is a possible warning sign, not proof of lost self-correction.
IN PREPARATION
Going deeper
A research manuscript on frames of reference, observability and recoverability in dynamical systems is in progress. It will be presented here only after it is complete and has been scientifically approved. Until then, this space shows only the open question:
Can two systems produce the same observations and still differ in whether they can correct themselves after a disturbance?
VERIFIED SOURCES
Further research
From the BenchEWS programme
- Peer-reviewed paper in AIP Advances (2026): spectral compression under specified assumptions ↗
- CRTI closure paper: why dedicated CRTI development was discontinued ↗
- Understanding BenchEWS – research orientation →
- What BenchEWS is →
- Evidence matrix and limitations →
Background for the film and this page
- NASA: Earth Fact Sheet (orbital velocity, rotation) ↗
- Reid et al. 2019, ApJ 885, 131: rotation of the Milky Way at the Sun's position ↗
- Planck Collaboration 2020, A&A 641, A1: motion relative to the cosmic microwave background ↗
- Scheffer et al. 2009, Nature 461, 53–59: early-warning signals for critical transitions ↗